Beoardielingen foar AudD® Music Recognition
AudD® Music Recognition troch AudD, LLC
13 beoardielingen
- Wurdearring: 3 fan 5troch Park, 2 moannen lynIt keeps getting muted when using it. I don't hear anything until I refresh it.
Antwurd ûntwikkeler
21 dagen lyn pleatstReally sorry about the experience! We’ve now fixed the issues & bugs related to audio recording!
Starting with version 3.2.4 (it's live now! you can update the extension in Extensions -> Settings -> Check for Updates), audio should not be muted on any websites, and audio recording should work perfectly almost everywhere, including basically all video players.
(Thanks for taking the time to write the review! It marginally prompted us to actually spend effort figuring out the issue, getting help from the community, and finally fixing it. That took hundreds of lines of code.) - Wurdearring: 3 fan 5troch Firefox-brûker 18877700, 5 moannen lyn
- Wurdearring: 3 fan 5troch Samg381, 7 moannen lynI have two complaints with this plugin. The first issue is with respect to the pricing and API configuration- the setup of which is somewhat convoluted for most users, and there is no free tier, similar to Shazam, and it is unclear what benefit the API key brings, or when it is active / actively assisting recognition, or disabled or invalid. My second issue relates to the muting issue, where your browser tab stops producing audio when the recognition button is pressed. This probably has something to do with the way this app handles audio pipelines in the browser, but it is annoying nonetheless. Other than that, this plugin works mostly well, and I appreciate the developers for maintaining it.
Antwurd ûntwikkeler
ien moanne lyn pleatstYou don't need to have an API token to use the extension. Apologies if the interface is not clear on that. The field to provide an API token is only for people who otherwise have an API account and, e.g., want to use the extension for work purposes. If you don't have one, you can leave the field empty and use the extension completely for free, with the temporary exception of a small number of websites where there’s a lot of abuse (on the order of $200/300 per month in server costs).
Really sorry about the experience with audio recording! We’ve now fixed the issues & bugs related to it!
Starting with version 3.2.4 (it's live now! you can update the extension in Extensions -> Settings -> Check for Updates), audio should not be muted on any websites, and audio recording should work perfectly almost everywhere, including basically all video players.
(Thanks for taking the time to write the review! It marginally prompted us to actually spend effort figuring out the issue, getting help from the community, and finally fixing it. That took hundreds of lines of fairly complicated code.) Antwurd ûntwikkeler
ien moanne lyn pleatstSorry, due to a lot of abuse (on the order of $200-300/month in server costs), we’ve disabled it on Twitch (though left it working for users with API tokens).- Wurdearring: 3 fan 5troch NicCrimson, 7 moannen lynWorks really well, Recently there is a bug where it mutes the tab's audio when searching and has to reload to get back audio. Also can't use because of error:
"Recognition failed: authorization failed: no api_token passed and the limit was reached. Get an api_token from dashboard.audd.io and make sure you're passing the token in the `api_token` parameter."Antwurd ûntwikkeler
21 dagen lyn pleatstReally sorry about the experience! We’ve now fixed the issues & bugs related to audio recording!
Starting with version 3.2.4 (it's live now! you can update the extension in Extensions -> Settings -> Check for Updates), audio should not be muted on any websites, and audio recording should work perfectly almost everywhere, including basically all video players.
(Thanks for taking the time to write the review! It marginally prompted us to actually spend effort figuring out the issue, getting help from the community, and finally fixing it. That took hundreds of lines of fairly complicated code.) - Wurdearring: 3 fan 5troch AndyArtistics, 7 moannen lynThis worked completely fine, and technically still does, but now whenever I use it completely cuts the audio so i can't hear anything until i disable and reload a tab
Antwurd ûntwikkeler
21 dagen lyn pleatstWe’ve fixed this issue!
Starting with version 3.2.4 (it's live now! you can update the extension in Extensions -> Settings -> Check for Updates), audio should not be muted on any websites, and audio recording should work perfectly almost everywhere, including basically all video players.
(Thanks for taking the time to write the review! It marginally prompted us to actually spend effort figuring out the issue, getting help from the community, and finally fixing it. That took hundreds of lines of code.) - Wurdearring: 3 fan 5troch Karam Jameel Moore, ien jier lyn
- Wurdearring: 3 fan 5troch GrisburT, ien jier lynThe extension used to work perfectly, but since I changed computers the extension doesn't recognize anything at all.
- Wurdearring: 3 fan 5troch 5sam6, ien jier lynThis extension only works when it wants to. Would have been a good extension but for some reason it cannot recognize songs half the time. When i still used chrome i used AVA music which performed way better than this. Sadly this is the best option available so i hope they manage to update this extension and make it better.
- Wurdearring: 3 fan 5troch Plain Bagel, ien jier lynGreat at finding most songs but hard to find more obscure ones, expand your song db pls
- Wurdearring: 3 fan 5troch Anexzs, 2 jierren lynIt's simple, works, and doesn't bug the audio. Though, I think they need to up their database a little cause a lot of songs I try to detect don't get any results.
Update: Requires a token, which has a free trial you can only use for a few weeks or so. Disappointing - Wurdearring: 3 fan 5troch Firefox-brûker 12744283, 2 jierren lynIn my previous review, I gave this extension a 1-star rating due to a bug that required a subscription to perform any actions. However, I believe the issue has since been fixed, so I decided to give this extension another try.
According to the addon description, it claims to "Identify any music from any website in your browser." One might assume that this means you can freely identify any song on any page, considering the extension is open-source and the developer has a donation link on the page. Unfortunately, that assumption is incorrect. It does work for free on YouTube and Twitch (and possibly on some other websites), but on any other site, an active subscription to the service is required. Regrettably, the developer failed to disclose this information in the description.
Regarding YouTube song recognition, I attempted to identify songs on lofi girl music streams (both lofi and synthwave radios), but it failed most of the time. This was surprising, given that it was practically the same use case as shown in the demo video.
For standalone songs, the recognition works fairly well. However, when there is someone speaking over the song, such as in let's play videos or on Twtich streams, its reliability significantly decreases, even for popular music. Based on my limited testing, it was able to identify only 2 out of 10 songs in different attempts. That's quite disappointing.Antwurd ûntwikkeler
2 jierren lyn pleatstHi, thanks a lot for the update!
- There are 10 websites where the extension is not supposed to work without an API token, to prevent people (usually, employees of these websites' owners) from using the extension for work. The list:
"watzatsong", "coub", "gyrostream.com", "cms.onerpm.com", "rumedia.io", "decabroda.studio", "adsintegrity.net", "file:///", "v16-tcs.tiktokcdn.com", "rmxindia.in", "vk.com".
The extension should work on any website that doesn't have any of these strings in the URL.
Can you please send us a link where the extension refused to identify the song? This is likely a bug (perhaps a false positive match with the strings above?). Our email is firefox@audd.io.
- Regarding YouTube streams, some of them broadcast songs that are "not copyrighted"/were not released on digital platforms, and unfortunately we don't have them in our DB.
- 2 out of 10 songs with people talking over is quite a low number; can you try increasing the recording length in the settings to 12 seconds and see if that improves?
We really appreciate you giving the extension another try and making the update! - Wurdearring: 3 fan 5troch RokeJulianLockhart, 3 jierren lynSlow to recognize when compared to Shazam. No history, much less synchronized to something like last.fm. No automatic music recognition. Doesn't modify the colouration of its graphical interface to adhere to theme of browser nor system. Would like a link on lyrics' page to view the lyrics at their origin rather than within the extension.
Antwurd ûntwikkeler
3 jierren lyn pleatstHi, thank you so much for the feedback!
You can change the speed of music recognition (the number of seconds it records the audio for before sending it to the music recognition API) in the settings. Were you able to see the settings section?
There is history. Every identified song is added to it. Do you not see it? It’s displayed below the identified song or if there’s no audio on the current page.
Can you please tell us what you mean by automatic music recognition?
Thank you for the feedback regarding changing the graphical interface. We’d be happy if someone contributed to the extension (it’s open source and published on GitHub) and added the design and support for the various browser themes. It wouldn’t be great if everything is dark and there was our extension with a bright background. Do you, by any chance, have examples of extensions that are great at doing this?
The music recognition API doesn’t provide links to the origin of the lyrics. The idea is that it’s possible to read along. Do you feel like it would be better if, instead, there was a link that opened google for the lyrics or searched on some service that provides lyrics?
We’d really appreciate the answers or any other help with that!
Feel free to contact us via firefox@audd.io.