Orbit [Beta]: AI Assistant and Content Summarizer 的评价
Orbit [Beta]: AI Assistant and Content Summarizer 作者: Firefox
10 条评价
- Though it works, there are few things to be dealt with:
1. This isn't open source.
How can users just provide all their privacy content without knowing whether their data will be abused?
If it's open source add-on, at least somebody can audit its code.
2. Lack of customisation ability.
Users may have their own prompts to make Orbit speak in certain style they preferred, or summarise their emails in some structured format, but there isn't any option for us to do so.
3. Support more languages.
Well, if your statement is true, the instance you hold is Mistral 7B.
Then why Orbit only speaks few language (or only English)?
Mistral 7B is a multi-lingual model, so I guess you either etched some prompt into it or the model behind the closed-source interface isn't mistral 7B (that's why I want open source, otherwise we don't know what exactly happened there).
4. Font
The current font size and style are not reader-friendly at all. - It struggles significantly with describing entertainment videos. Mixtral makes many mistakes and overlooks important moments, as if it doesn't understand the sequence of the narrative and what to write. The descriptions are too concise. It would be beneficial to recognize when more details are needed and when they are not. In any case, I hope this can be improved, as the concept itself is great. It would also be nice to consider using Llama 3, GPT-4o Mini, or Claude 3 instead of Mixtral7B.
开发者回应
发布于 5 个月前Thank you for your kind feedback! We are currently testing a few alternatives. It helps us to know where Mixtral 7B is not meeting the expectations. - 评分 2 / 5来自 Firefox 用户 14489236, 5 个月前Is the extension really that important that they have to put that ball right on the webpage? I guess not. Mozilla should stick to its own style guides & established best practices. A toolbar button would have sufficed.
- Works good, but extremely annoying UI.
This adds a massive floating element to all webpages by default. You can make it smaller, but it's still on top of pages instead of better places built for add-ons, like the toolbar. Imagine if other extensions did it like this, it would be massively annoying. It's like the Clippy/BonziBuddy UI, just duller.
You can't summarize the things you usually want to summarize either, like links you haven't clicked on yet. That's probably the most useful use-case for summarization, "do I want to consume the contents on this link or is it clickbait?". This plugin can't do that, the UI is both intrusive and useless.
The Kagi extension has a WAY better UI (but the summarization itself is often broken unfortunately, so alternatives are needed.)开发者回应
发布于 7 个月前This is valuable feedback for our team! Thank you.
The ability to summarize links on a page is a great idea and one we'll add to our backlog.
We'll continue to evolve the UI thanks to great feedback like this. 开发者回应
发布于 7 个月前Thank you for this feedback! The newest version now provides a "minimal" view in settings that removed the floating orb.- I'm glad Mozilla's trying for more privacy-conscious AI alternatives. The functionality is fine.
But I'm not going to have a giant, animated blob covering the corner of every website. You have a toolbar, an extensions menu, a context menu, and shortcut keys. Use any or all of those to activate an extension. (Heck, you even have an AI sidebar pane experiment. Why isn't Orbit in there?) - 评分 2 / 5来自 GobiNoKitsune, 8 个月前The summaries are alright, nothing ground-breaking you can't find elsewhere. My main complaints are that it puts a 100x100 floating widget on your webpages -- who the hell thought this was a good idea? You have an extensions toolbar for a reason, Mozilla -- use it.
开发者回应
发布于 7 个月前Thank you for the feedback! It's helps us iteratively improve the product. Let us know if the tweaks we've made made it a more positive experience for you.- 评分 2 / 5来自 Firefox 用户 18596452, 8 个月前