YesScript2 のレビュー
YesScript2 作成者: Andras Horvath
Andras Horvath による応答
開発者の返信
投稿日時: 8年前Yes, you are correct, it blocks almost all images on daily mail - let me explain you what happens here.
The primary goal of this extension is to give you the control to be able to block or allow scrips on specific websites. You don't have any other control without extensions with your stock browser but turning off scripting entirely for every pages. That's not useful though, hence my development.
Daily mail loads images using scripts and this is a tendency where the industry go. However pushing functionality from server side back to the users (by running scripts on their computers instead of on the server) uses much more resources on the users' devices and so their battery go off much faster. This is one problem, and the other is that websites and web services become more and more vulnerable for hacker attacks (using cross site scripting and many other technics).
I'm not saying you should turn off scripts on all sites because it might break functionality of it. However if you don't trust some site or they use heavy scripting making your device slow or you worry about being hacked through that site, then it is a good practice to block scripts from that site if you want to visit it anyway.
So this tool is just an option for you that the stock browser does not offer. There are other options for you like using NoScript extension but teaching your browser for every domain for every script calls seems a tedious and long work. It varies whom it's worth it to.
So you have several options to solve a problem if one arises, it is up to you which one fits you the most. These options might not be perfect but it's better to have more than less.
Regarding the original YesScript, I don't know what it does under the hood because I did not study its code thoroughly but instead I've rewritten mine entirely on my own. But as far as I know it should do the same like blocking a web site's scripts entirely. But if you say that it lets the images load for Daily mail, then it may block scripts belonging only to the original domain and not blocking all of them. If that's the case (I don't know) then my version may give better security and save more resources. But I have to say that the developer made a really nice work creating it in my opinion.
I'd also like to mention that one of my other priority when writing this extension was to create an extremely small code set so it can be audited much easier making it more trustful. The less lines of code, the more reliable and secure a solution can be. Currently the main code consists of 81 lines only.
Thank you.
The primary goal of this extension is to give you the control to be able to block or allow scrips on specific websites. You don't have any other control without extensions with your stock browser but turning off scripting entirely for every pages. That's not useful though, hence my development.
Daily mail loads images using scripts and this is a tendency where the industry go. However pushing functionality from server side back to the users (by running scripts on their computers instead of on the server) uses much more resources on the users' devices and so their battery go off much faster. This is one problem, and the other is that websites and web services become more and more vulnerable for hacker attacks (using cross site scripting and many other technics).
I'm not saying you should turn off scripts on all sites because it might break functionality of it. However if you don't trust some site or they use heavy scripting making your device slow or you worry about being hacked through that site, then it is a good practice to block scripts from that site if you want to visit it anyway.
So this tool is just an option for you that the stock browser does not offer. There are other options for you like using NoScript extension but teaching your browser for every domain for every script calls seems a tedious and long work. It varies whom it's worth it to.
So you have several options to solve a problem if one arises, it is up to you which one fits you the most. These options might not be perfect but it's better to have more than less.
Regarding the original YesScript, I don't know what it does under the hood because I did not study its code thoroughly but instead I've rewritten mine entirely on my own. But as far as I know it should do the same like blocking a web site's scripts entirely. But if you say that it lets the images load for Daily mail, then it may block scripts belonging only to the original domain and not blocking all of them. If that's the case (I don't know) then my version may give better security and save more resources. But I have to say that the developer made a really nice work creating it in my opinion.
I'd also like to mention that one of my other priority when writing this extension was to create an extremely small code set so it can be audited much easier making it more trustful. The less lines of code, the more reliable and secure a solution can be. Currently the main code consists of 81 lines only.
Thank you.
合計レビュー数: 78
- 5 段階中 5 の評価Firefox ユーザー 18890067 によるレビュー (5ヶ月前)Using it for a couple of years now and on a daily basis. I love the option of no js, only local js or all js. Beautiful piece of work!
- 5 段階中 5 の評価Firefox ユーザー 17811070 によるレビュー (2年前)I find the YesScript2 add-on to be very useful in blocking scripts on websites that won't let you read without agreeing to a subscription or paying a fee. YesScript2 is extremely easy to use and very effective in blocking unwanted scripts. I love this add-on and I just wish it was available for my android cell phone. Thank you Andras!
- Brokes both "To DeepL translation" add-on & website (https://www.deepl.com/translator), even in YesScript no-blocking state (grey).
(DeepL states that it is not Internet Explorer compatible — while I am using Firefox — and advises to use Edge Browser instead).
Also reported on the To DeepL translation add-on page. - 5 段階中 1 の評価Sebastian A によるレビュー (4年前)I apologize for 1 star rating, I can't find a way to message you. I noticed today that this add on is active even when it's in no-blocking mode, as it's blocking recaptcha. This makes it pretty much unusable. Much appreciated if you have the time to fix! If you reply I will change to 5 stars just so I know you got it!
- 5 段階中 5 の評価Firefox ユーザー 13276249 によるレビュー (4年前)Wow, I don´t understand why this app is not much, much more popular. It gets rid of so many pesky scripts bits. Loving it!
- 5 段階中 5 の評価Firefox ユーザー 16835969 によるレビュー (4年前)
- 5 段階中 2 の評価backwoodsman によるレビュー (4年前)It blocks reCAPTCHA even when set to no blocking. Apparently it's still doing something even when it's supposed to be doing nothing.
- 5 段階中 5 の評価Firefox ユーザー 16648581 によるレビュー (5年前)
- 5 段階中 5 の評価Firefox ユーザー 16560640 によるレビュー (5年前)Works as advertised, and is very helpful on many of the sites I frequent. The only change I'd like to see is in the toolbar icon. It's hard for me (and maybe other colorblind people) to tell the colors apart. It would be nice if the icon changed shape or maybe showed a letter (F, H, or N?) to indicate full, half, or no blocking.
- 5 段階中 5 の評価Firefox ユーザー 14250880 によるレビュー (5年前)
- I've used YesScript2 for a couple of years to get me past paywalls, which usually works well I can get into most sites. But since I updated Firefox to Version 80 yesterday I can't get into my hotmail, it locks up for a minute or so and then puts up an error screen. All other sites work fine. I don't have the problem if YesScript2 is disabled, only when it's active. Using this forum to bring the developer's attention to the problem so maybe they can fix it.
- This is a quite useful addon. However, only recently (2019-December), this started breaking some of my commonly visited websites - repl.it. I had a hard time tracking down that this was indeed the offending addon.
The third (or default) mode - unfiltered - or no blocking doesn't prevent it from breaking the webpage with "Content Security Policy: The page’s settings blocked the loading of a resource at...".
I request the developer to please look into this. I've had to disable this addon entirely to get the website working. This addon is a must for browsing websites that throw unsuspecting clicks at you, but this simply breaks a really small fraction of the web for me. - 5 段階中 5 の評価Firefox ユーザー 15446614 によるレビュー (6年前)
- 5 段階中 5 の評価Henry Mulligan によるレビュー (6年前)
- 5 段階中 4 の評価Joe JoKeRz によるレビュー (6年前)This add-on was fantastic, I say was because it seems to have stopped working. Anytime I blacklist a page it doesn't stick, when the page refreshes the icon is grey again (instead of red) and scripts will work/load for the page.
- 5 段階中 4 の評価Ahmad Gharbeia によるレビュー (6年前)It would be great if this extension placed its toggle-button in the URL bar. This gives the indication that its effect is URL-specific.
Another extension that does this is : https://github.com/meetDeveloper/Quick-JS-Switcher
YesScript2 supersedes the fore-mentioned extension by providing the three-state control. - 5 段階中 5 の評価Firefox ユーザー 15267736 によるレビュー (6年前)Very very helpful. Blocks lot of unnecessary ads, pop ups etc and helps to load page very fast! Can't say about every other sites but this is great for me.